Why You Should Consider Incorporating Manure Separation On Your Dairy

Rob Plank
By: Rob Plank February 1, 2019
Managing your dairy manure is never simple. Even if you simply transfer the manure directly from your cow alleys to a storage pond or lagoon, you will eventually need to clean out that location and figure out where to take those nutrients. Manure solid-liquid separation can help you manage your manure and allow you to be more strategic about the placement of your nutrients.

Benefits

Managing your dairy manure is never simple. Even if you simply transfer the manure directly from your cow alleys to a storage pond or lagoon, you will eventually need to clean out that location and figure out where to take those nutrients. Manure solid-liquid separation can help you manage your manure and allow you to be more strategic about the placement of your nutrients. 

There are a number of benefits that can be achieved by incorporating one or more solid-liquid separation methods on your dairy. 

Making your own bedding

If your dairy is bedding on sawdust or another similar form of organic bedding, adding a manure separator may allow you to create your own bedding source. This can be achieved with either a Screw Press or Roll Press system. The separated manure fibers can be mixed with your bedding or used independent by themselves. If used by themselves, adding a Bedding Dryer can really help with reducing moisture and bacteria levels. 

Flexibility with hauling and pumping the manure

Manure can be extremely challenging to process simply because it is so unpredictable. The manure can contain ear tags, long fibers, string and concrete chunks, to name just a few. This foreign material wreaks havoc on pumping systems and downstream processing equipment. Installing a manure separator removes all this unwanted debris immediately in a more manageable manner along with manure fibers. With the manure fibers and debris removed, the remaining effluent can be transferred via pumping system to trucks or fields with reduced risk of plugging pipes, pumps and nozzles. In some cases, it allows for the irrigation of water and nutrients that wasn’t possible before.

Better process water

In many cases, supernatant (the cleaner portion of the manure water) is recycled back from storage lagoons for flushing cow lanes, cow holding areas, and flume pipes. Adding manure separation equipment prior to manure storages reduces the organic loading in the lagoon, which yields higher quality return water to the barns.  Often, water can be reused immediately from the separation equipment, eliminating the need to pump water back and forth from barn to storage.

Reduced lagoon size and loading

Processing your manure with a form of solid-liquid separation can reduce the required lagoon size for your dairy. It also reduces the organic loading going into the lagoon, which makes it less energy intensive to remove. Cornell University’s Pro-Dairy program published a paper studying several mechanical solid-liquid separation methods and concluded that separation can reduce required lagoon size by up to 30%.

Strategic placement of nutrients

Incorporating solid-liquid separation allows nutrients to be more strategically placed. Similarly as in point #2, by removing the large fibers and unwanted debris from the manure, the remaining liquid containing the bulk of the nutrients can be transported, transferred and applied with greater flexibility. The liquid effluent no longer needs to be hauled to fields with tankers and trucks, but can be pumped and applied strategically with irrigation and injection systems. The separated fibers, due to their lower bulk density, can be hauled further at a lower cost.

Disadvantages

There are also some disadvantages to solid-liquid separation that can't be overlooked.

Two separate manure streams to manage

The separated fibers will need to be periodically moved and stacked. This is accomplished on most dairies with either a skid steer or large loader. The amount of time needed depends on the size of dairy but can sometimes take multiple hours per day. Also, instead of hauling the manure with a single style piece of equipment, usually a manure tanker, a box spreader is needed to haul and spread the separated fibers. If the dairy doesn’t already own one, this can be an additional capital expense.

Increased operating and maintenance costs

Adding separation to your dairy will increase your operation and maintenance costs. In most cases, it means adding at least one electric motor, usually two when an additional pump is needed. There’s also the additional labor that’s required to periodically clean, inspect and fix the components in the system. These increased costs cannot be ignored. 

Increased capital costs

This capital cost goes further than just the equipment. There are concrete, structures, supports, plumbing and electrical costs to account for too.  In cold climates that get below freezing, a building with additional heat is required to keep the equipment operational during the winter months. 

Options

There are multiple ways to accomplish manure separation. These methods range from simple to very complex ways to remove fibers and nutrients. Several of the more common, and relatively simpler methods are described below. 

Rotary Screen

This technology can be used across a wide range of industries. It can be found processing food waste, screening wastewater and sorting minerals. This relatively simple technology uses a rotating drum composed of mesh or perforated plate. The material to be processed can be introduced either to the inside (internally fed) or outside (externally fed) of the screen. Particles are captured on the screen while liquid and fines travel through. Spraybars are common and brushes can be added to help keep the screen clean. These screens provide great separation for manure systems with potential for bypass sand. 

Inclined Screen

Inclined screens, sometimes called sidehill screens, banana screens or slope screens are, as the name implies, large, flat or curved screens that are set on a specific angle close to vertical. Material is pumped through the top and allowed to cascade down the screen. Fibers are separated and dewatered on the face of the screen before falling off. One of the advantages of this screen is no moving parts. Some screens incorporate wash bars and vibrating motors to aid in screen cleaning. The large advantage is no electrical requirements.

Vibrating Screen

There are multiple variations to this type of screener, but they all use a vibrating motor to move the screen in either a circular or elliptical motion to aid in particle separation and impart movement to the separated material. These screens have a high processing capacity for the relatively small footprint. These screens require periodic cleaning.  

Drag Chain and Trough

These systems use a drag chain located within an inclined trough, the bottom of which is built from screen material. The chain is slowly pulled upward toward the discharge. As it is pulled upward, it cleans away fibers that are captured on the screen and drags them to the discharge.  

Roll Press

Roll Press separators are a secondary separator used in series with a Rotary Drum to dewater thickened manure. Material is fed between two rotating rolls, which apply a high pressure zone between them. One of the rolls contains small openings, which allow water to drain through while retaining fibers. These machines have small overall screening area, so they aren’t used for primary separation. 

Screw Press

Screw Presses are compact separation and dewatering machines. They contain a rotating screw shaft within a screen. As material is conveyed into the body of the machine, the screw advances it forward past the screening surfaces. Fibers that are captured on the screen are wiped off and advanced forward by the screw. As these fibers accumulate at the discharge, they form a “plug” of material that is highly compressed and dewatered. These versatile separation machines provide great separation in a compact footprint. Due to high tolerances and high pressure zones, they are prone to abrasive wear. 

Concrete Storages, Weeping Walls, etc.

These methods are effective at removing a portion of the larger fibers and material that will settle with gravity. Essentially, manure is conveyed into a large settling area that creates retention time sufficient for the material to settle. In the case of a weeping wall or variations of them, there are areas in the walls or floors that allow liquids to drain through. Fibrous material tends to blind over the drainage areas rather quickly, rendering them ineffective for dewatering. These systems can be labor-intensive during cleanout. 

Other options

More complex methods include centrifuges, ultrafiltration membranes, disc presses, belt filter presses and chemical dosing systems. These complex methods are generally more effective at removing solids but require higher capital expenditures and operating costs. These higher costs must be weighed against the benefit of greater solids removal. 

Adding a manure solid-liquid separation system on your dairy is often a great way to manage your manure nutrients more strategically and allow you to implement methods of manure transfer and application that are more economical. There are multiple methods for achieving the manure separation goals of your dairy, so look carefully before choosing the method that is best suited for dairy needs and management style. 

Contact McLanahan
Tags: Bedding Management, Dairy, Manure Management